Social Dilemma-Would You Have Brought This Soda Back to the Store??

Today's social dilemma happened to me yesterday. I did some grocery shopping after work and one of the items I bought was an eight pack of bottled diet soda. They were the smaller bottles (I'm trying to break my soda habit). Anyway, I bought them, brought them home. When I pulled into the driveway, with it being such a nice day, my neighbor was outside and came over to help me bring the bags into the house. So she did and we were unpacking the groceries and she was about to put the soda in the fridge for me and noticed something wrong. Underneath the plastic wrapping, one of the eight bottles had been packed with no cover on it. But it was packed so tightly that it didn't even leak. No spillage at all. It was amazing. I thought it was cool. She told me to hop back into my car right away and go get another eight pack. I didn't think it was a big deal but I called my sweetie and yep, the same answer, bring the soda back. If it had been just me alone, I would have kept it at home and just thrown away that one bottle. But instead I schlepped back to the grocery store and exchanged it. They all thought it was amazing too tho. Anyway, question is, would you have just kept it and not gone back to the store like me, or would you have immediately brought it back? Let me know what you think on the TRY Facebook page.